924 Columbus Ave NY, NY 10025   |   212.222.4022

Loyalty Program

Welcome To Pie Pie Pizza

We’ve been making pizza for over 20 years and it shows in the way we serve you with a smile and in every tasty bite! Pie Pie Pizza, is a neighborhood staple on the UWS since 2011, an unassuming Pizza Joint crankin out Authentic Italian faves like Margherita, Pepperoni & Meat Lovers & modern faves like Hawaiian, Buffalo Chicken, Veggie & Brisket Meatball! We have a variety of Calzones too!

From the beginning, our mission was to use the best ingredients while keeping our prices low. We only use top quality Wisconsin Mozzarella, Italian Plum Tomatoes, and a blend of Italian flour and domestic unbleached flour. We take special care to perfectly slowly ferment our dough and boy, you can taste the difference! We source our meats exclusively from Pat La Frida, making our meatballs with fresh ground brisket inhouse! Now THAT’s Italian.


924 Columbus Ave
New York, New York 10025


Sun – 11:00am-8:00pm
Mon – 11:00am-8:00pm
Tue – 11:00am-9:15pm
Wed – 11:00am-9:15pm
Thu – 11:00am-9:15pm
Fri – 11:00am-10:15pm
Sat – 11:00am-10:15pm