restaurant 0D0A4144.jpg

Eat. Drink. Relax.

About Us

PIE PIE pizza is a classic NYC pizzeria. Proudly serving the New York's Upper West Side area since 2011.

Since then, our mission has been to provide high-quality Pizza using natural flour (never bleached, never bromated), RBGH free Cheeses and the best plum tomatoes.

For all those that wish to have a slice that throws you back to the 80's, this is it!

Learn More
the original 0D0A4163.jpg
Chicken bacon ranch 0D0A4375.jpg
Chicken bacon ranch 0D0A4378_edited.jpg

Food for Every Mood

0D0A4432_edited.jpg

Brisket Meatballs

We proudly use Pat LaFrieda's premium Brisket Ground Beef to make our meatballs daily in house. Oven Roasted with fine herbs, Parmigiano and cage free eggs.

Even Nonna would be proud!

Pizza Dough

Chicken Wings

This latest addition to our menu has already become our customers’ favorite. No Antibiotics ever Chicken Wings, served with our house made signature sauce.

wings and pickles house fries 0D0A4382_edited.jpg

We Knead the Dough

Our Dough is made with the finest flour's and slowly fermented 48-72 hours, always prepared to perfection. Share our pizza with friends or have it all to yourself—you’ll enjoy it till the very last bite.

Contact

924 Columbus Avenue, New York, NY, USA

212 222 4022

Pizza Dough

Opening Hours

Dine In or Take Away

Monday - Saturday: 11am - 11pm
Sunday: 11am - 7pm